My blog-friend JES shared with us the other day a few of his 'guilty pleasures' (in the comment-thread to his post reviewing Stuart Neville's thriller The Twelve [UK title; just published in the US as The Ghosts of Belfast]), and he challenged me to produce a list of mine. As you can see from my post title here, it's that word 'guilty' I have a problem with. I've never been much of a believer in guilt, finding it one of the most superfluous of the emotions. I take a kind of pride in my more eccentric habits and preferences, and feel not a shred of guilt about them (well, with the possible exception of playing computer games, that is - I do give myself a bit of a hard time over that on occasions). If I am wary of discussing these things openly, it is only because I fear provoking a censorious response from others. I know that these are tastes which are perhaps not widely shared, and which may in some cases even arouse moral disdain or physical disgust. I know that these are habits which I can really only practise in private, and must abandon altogether whenever I have a houseguest, flatmate, or girlfriend. At the very least, I fear my friends may be shocked or disapproving - or just disbelieving - of these revelations because they do not seem to be consonant with their general perception of me: surely such a sporty chap can't revel in gluttony so? surely a man of such culture can't enjoy heavy metal music? surely such a cinema snob can't have a soft spot for chick flicks? My circumspection, then, about discussing such matters should properly be attributed not to guilt but to shame. Here then are (some of) my favourite... Shameful Pleasures Computer driving games I have occasionally played other kinds of computer games - role-playing, strategy, shooters, etc. - but soon start to find them terribly dull. Even with games involving multiple elements, like Driver, The Getaway, and Grand Theft Auto, it was mainly the driving that appealed to me about them. Only driving games really seem to tap into my obsessive streak, my passion for the pursuit of perfection: I love gradually whittling down a lap time, a few tenths or hundredths of a second at a time, over the course of dozens, perhaps hundreds of repetitions. I rather fear that, after so many years of relentlessly pushing up to, and somewhat beyond the ragged edge in driving simulations (and finding crashing really rather fun!), I wouldn't be safe behind the wheel of a real car now. Eating ice-cream out of the tub Ah, decadence! I am quite capable of eating a half-litre tub in a single sitting (although I try to restrain myself from succumbing to such over-indulgence too often). Rum'n'raisin is my favourite of the flavours readily available to me out here in China; although mango is also good, and I can occasionally get a decent cookies'n'cream. Eating baked beans out of the can Heinz Baked Beans, that is - the lurid, unnaturally orange and dangerously sweet ones that have long been a centrepiece of every UK childhood, but are apparently uknown around most of the rest of the world. Intermittently available as a 'luxury import' from certain of the foreigner-oriented supermarkets here. Eating them warm on buttered toast is, of course, the classic childhood nostalgia fix, an ultimate comfort food. But for me a very close second favourite means of consuming them is the perhaps rather rarer - maybe even unique? - method of spooning them cold directly out of the can (ideally, with one or two pickled onions dropped in the top, to vary up the flavour and texture). I have had (female) flatmates who thought this utterly appalling. Apartment-bound naturism One of the best things about living alone (and on an upper floor, with no neighbours within any kind of snooping range) is that you can spend a lot of the day naked. I particularly like going out on my balcony early in the morning to do some starkers tai chi - aping the elegant movements of the old ladies in the park below (I can see them, but they can't see me!). Of course, it can lead to embarrassment when the man calls to read the water-meter. Drinking in bed Even more than eating in bed, this seems to me the height of cosseting self-indulgence. I quite often retire to bed for the night with a small can of beer or a snifter of whisky, while I try to finish off a chapter of a book. There are few moments of more perfect relaxation in my life. Of course, it does quite often lead to messy spillages, if I fall asleep before I've finished. The music of AC/DC This is one of those I alluded to above, a pleasure which those who don't know the music will find it difficult to appreciate; and something which many people seem to regard as an unlikely enthusiasm of mine. I grew up almost exclusively devoted to classical music, an avid listener to BBC Radio 3 throughout my childhood. I disdained my elder brother's rock'n'roll record collection, most of which seemed to be fixated on odd colour references - Pink Floyd, Deep Purple. I didn't develop much of an interest in rock music until I started at college (in fact, I discovered AC/DC serendipitously through a fellow student, who had a room a few doors down the corridor from me and was playing some very loudly on the first day of the new term; that was how we met 25 years ago, and we're still best friends). Many of my friends still seem to picture me as a high-brow nerd; I badger them to come to classical concerts with me, and even to the ballet. My profound admiration for AC/DC seems to them somehow out-of-kilter with these other tastes. And heck, even admirers of the genre are sometimes disparaging of AC/DC, suggesting that they are a little simplistic and repetitive, jeering that they have made the same album over and over again (I think I've complained on here before [although I can't now find the link] that Angus only just makes it into Rolling Stone's list of the 'Top 100 Greatest Guitarists of All Time'; I'd put him in the Top 20). Tosh! They are the best rock'n'roll band ever, with dozens of - quite diverse - classic head-bangy anthems. And Angus Young is just an exquisite, heavily blues-influenced guitar player. If you don't get this, you have no soul. Romantic films And I don't just mean rom-coms here (although I have a weakness for them too) but slushy romantic melodramas - particularly from the good old black & white days. I used to watch hundreds of old films on afternoon and early evening TV when I was a kid, so there's an element of personal nostalgia tied up with my continuing fondness for this kind of film now. My heart flip-flops a little whenever I come across a golden oldie like Random Harvest or Queen Christina or Portrait of Jennie in my local DVD store. |
Saturday, October 03, 2009
List of the Month - Shameful Pleasures
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
8 comments:
This wonderful compilation is deserving of a few responses.
"I have had (female) flatmates who thought this utterly appalling."
They were right, of course.
As for AC/DC, the old boys are already sold out for a series of gigs down under this year. I confess to having 'highway to hell' on my walkman. Then again, I have the Rolf Harris classic 'two little boys' as well.
I've been well and properly one-upped. Excellent work, but now I'm worrying if my own confessions might have been too much on the timid side.
On the guilt/shame thing...
(1) A teacher of American literature I once knew (that is, I knew the teacher; she didn't specialize in just what I knew) said something I never forgot about guilt. Talking about Hawthorne, she said something to the effect that unlike many of his time period, Hawthorne didn't wish for a world without sin: he wished for a world without guilt. I wonder if she really meant shame?
(2) I don't think I've ever heard the phrase "shameful pleasures"; it's always "guilty." (Maybe specifically US usage?) There's something about "shameful" which to me implies really bad things -- disloyalty, betrayal, flat-out cruelty, and so on. You're right that the things in my catalogue, and in yours for that matter, aren't deserving of guilt, but I'd argue that they're even less deserving of shame. Maybe "sneaking pleasures"?
(3) If you don't know of her already, you might want to sample some of author Barbara Holland's works. I'm thinking of The Joy of Drinking and, especially, Endangered Pleasures -- subtitled In Defense of Naps, Bacon, Martinis, Profanity, and Other Indulgences. The Amazon page on the latter includes the handy "Look Inside!" feature; I think you might enjoy it. Just reading the Table of Contents provides some laughs, like "Using People" and "Driving Beltless." (Can you get Amazon over there???)
Can I get Amazon? Sometimes.
I'll have to go and check this out. It seems to me like I've come across The Joy of Drinking somewhere... but perhaps it's just one of those books I've thought of writing myself.
To return to guilt and shame, JES (you had so many good points there, but I rather forgot about this post for a while), I think that for most categories of improper activity they ought to apply equally. However, the problem is that shame is external - you can only be shamed if your wrongdoing is exposed.
I suppose this might tend to make 'shameful' seem the stronger criticism in modern usage, because an offence has to be pretty egregious to become publicly known; whereas it is mostly only the smaller peccadilloes that are exclusively the preserve of our private guilt.
Unfortunately, public censure - at least in matters of individual taste and behaviour such as I was discussing here - is often based on stuffy and ill-founded codes of propriety for which I don't have much time. Therefore, any shyness I feel about discussing the quirks above is prompted by shame (an aversion to public censure) rather than guilt.
But you're right: 'shameful pleasures' isn't really an established collocation. I am trying to make it so.
Stuart, Two Little Boys is a great song. Though I prefer John Otway's rendition of it.
If you had cited Rolf's wobble-board cover of Stairway To Heaven, however, I think you would have been straying into shameful/guilty pleasures territory.
The Missus and her siblings used to take turns hosting family reunions in memory of their parents, who were born in the 1920s. When our turn came around, as a little memento of the occasion we made up a mix CD called Songs They Loved, containing music, obviously, that Tom and Mabel had danced to, sung, often listened to -- whatever.
I myself had never heard of many of the songs. For instance, Mabel had a particular fondness for the macabre, especially when seasoned with sentiment, and consequently she greatly favored a tune called Little Rosewood Casket, which manages to work the words "coffin" and "casket" into a song of heartbreak.
All of which is a lead-in to: I'd also never heard of Two Little Boys until then. (It wasn't Rolf Harris's version, obviously.)
A Civil War song, I imagine. I have for ages now been trying to track down a CD (I still haven't got my head around this MP3 downloading business) of the wonderful soundtrack to the Ken Burns documentary series on the war.
If you do a little search over on The Barstool, JES (sorry, searching and embedding links is still proving a little problematical for me), you will find a description of Mr Otway and his idiosyncratic performance of this song.
Who is the AC/DC fan?
The Shipping Forecast is great, especially the late night one followed by Sailing By
Post a Comment