Monday, January 12, 2009

A bon mot to end them all

"Everything has been said, and we are more than seven thousand years of human thought too late."

Jean de La Bruyère (1645-1696)

8 comments:

Anonymous said...

Do you think that this actually means something? If so, what?

Froog said...

I think it means that 'originality' is a delusion - an unimportant but often rather frustrating one.

And if the situation was depressing enough in the 1680s, how much worse is it today after another 300 and some years of bon mots.

Anonymous said...

Oh, is that what it means?
Very few of Jean de La Bruyère's epigrams are worth quoting: most of them seem to be meaningless, banal, obscure or just untrue. Perhaps they do not translate well.

Froog said...

I don't claim the familiarity with his work that you do, Teddy, but in general I rarely find any problem with translating French into English. (It is essentially the same language with different words. Chinese, Latin, Greek, even Russian seem to pose far more problems.)

This one, at least, seems good to me, and effectively translated.

I'll have to dig out some more, to check whether you are just talking out of your bottom.

Anonymous said...

I am not really familiar with de La B's works, but a quick scan through these quotes suggests that he was no Oscar Wilde. The one you have selected appears to mean that no-one has said or thought anything new and worthwhile since 5000 BC. This is as arrogant and fatuous as Francis Fukuyama's remark about the End of History.

Froog said...

Well, I take the chosen time period as a humorous overstatement. Though who knows what countless shrewd remarks may have gone unrecorded back in old Mesopotamia - maybe that really was a golden age of wit and philosophy.

Froog said...

I agree that J de la B was "no Wilde". Poor old Oscar was a hopeless crowd-pleaser, slave to the punchline always. Some of these lines from 200 years earlier are much better than anything of his.

I may well torture you, "Teddy", with a year of regular bons mots from from the French sage.

Anonymous said...

I think not. Farewell.